Like our previous style showdown between Stephanie Pratt and Paris Hilton, below is a battle of fashion-forward youngsters from the MTV Movie Awards Sunday night.

These two teens have actual talent. Who will prevail when casual and absolutely ripped Dancing with the Stars winner Shawn Johnson takes on Nickelodeon darling Miranda Cosgrove?

We know it’s tough, with such contrasting fashion statements, but you must decide.

 Shawn Johnson1 Miranda Cosgrove