Paula Abdul made some serious mistakes while commenting on American Idol on Tuesday night. She judged Jason Castro for 2 songs when he had just sang one song. Randy Jackson tried to tell her that it should be only for the first song but Paula continued her tirade about how hard it was to judge Jason.

Paula tried to explain how she made her goofy mistake. She said that she got mixed up when the producers gave different directions for judging this episode because each singer had two songs to sing instead of the usual one song. Paula threw in more confusion by saying that her negative critique was actually meant for David Cook. David had received some glowing praises from Paula previously for his song. Paula’s explanation was a mystery.paula-abdul